A Reflection on the Excellence of Solitude to Meditative Concentration
-Trung Thanh Nguyen From Vietnam
At the beginning of the chapter Meditative Concentration in Bodhicaryāvatāra, Śāntideva presents the importance of solitude on the practice of meditative concentration. Therefore, in this paper I will maintain a thesis that solitude is one of the most conducive conditions to meditative concentration because it plays an essential role on the practice of meditation to be “not troubled by distraction.” To demonstrate to my argument, firstly I will present how solitude should simply be understood with its definition and its classification; secondly I will present some pieces of evidence in favor of my position that why solitude plays an essential role to meditative concentration; and thirdly I will relate the importance of solitude to the engaging practice in the modern life.
Firstly, how should solitude simply be understood with its definition and its classification? Solitude, which Śāntideva mentions in this chapter, means to distance ourselves from two kinds of object: all attachment to the worldly affairs, and the mental wandering toward the objects of senses. Accordingly, we can understand that why solitude is classified into two kinds: the physical (outer) solitude, related with the worldly affairs; and the mental (inner) solitude, related with the mental wandering. Both kinds of solitude take an important role to create such conducive circumstances for the development of meditative concentration.
Secondly, why does solitude play an essential role to meditative concentration? According to Śāntideva, he points out the importance of solitude in the second verse of this chapter:
“In solitude, the mind and body
Are not troubled by distraction.
Therefore leave this worldly life
And totally abandon mental wandering.”1
He asserts that the essential role of solitude is one of the most important circumstances for the practice of meditative concentration in which “the mind and body are not troubled by distraction.” Without distractions, calm abiding (śamatha) is nourished, then afflictive obscurations are suppressed and merit is accumulated. Clear insight (vispaśyanā) is simultaneously developed. Consequently, the two obscurations of affliction and cognition are eradicated, wisdom is accumulated for the fruit of ultimate enlightenment. Therefore, Śāntideva encourages us to leave the outer distraction, the worldly life—related with the practice of physical solitude and abandon the inner distraction, the mental wandering—related with the practice of mental solitude, for the development of both śamatha and vispaśyanā meditative concentration. In detail, the practice of physical solitude is to give up attachment to beings and attachment to worldly gain; the practice of mental solitude is to abandon one’s craving for a lover and give up attachment to wealth and possessions. In addition, these two kinds of solitude have a relation of mutual assistance. According to Śāntideva, physical solitude confers its own blessing, namely, the fact that the distractions of body, speech, and mind naturally subside.2 He is not making an ultimate statement about how to live one’s life. He is just saying in order for the mind to become steady, we need to remove ourselves from the worldly life with useless distractions, at least for a short period of time. In this case, physical solitude is a support for mental solitude. By giving up attachment to beings and worldly gain, staying in such empty places, we can resolve to watch our mind and bring it under control—starting the practice of metal solitude. With this excellence of physical solitude, Śāntideva also encourages us to strive in profound meditation of the union of śamatha and vispaśyanā: the former to still his mind in the even state of calm abiding, the latter to subdue it with penetrative insight.3 In another case, when practitioners are well-trained with metal solitude, they would prefer to stay in physical solitude, choosing to live alone and keeping away from all outer distractions. Specially, the most important aspect of this practice is the mental solitude. In higher level of practice, advanced practitioners with well-trained and steady mind can engage their life in the society without any worries of outer distractions. Instead, they find these outer distractions as skillful means to support to the development of their mental solitude and generate the penetrative insight. In this case, we can reflect those images on the life of Bodhisattvas who also engage their life into the mundane world to help all sentient beings without any condition or worries about outer distractions. On their way of life, Bodhisattvas also find those engagements as supportive means to enrich themselves for the ultimate goal of Buddhahood.
Thirdly, how could we apply the practice of solitude in the modern life? With the swift development of technology and social medias, even though we can be alone in an empty place, we are still distracted with the communities by many social medias such as Facebook, Tweeter, Teams, … Therefore, to truly practice solitude, we need to effectively control ourselves from the outer distraction of social medias and modern technologies. For instance, we can find a time, when we switch off all social medias, to be truly trained in the practice of solitude—dwelling in the treasure moments of the steady mind, giving up all worries about the worldly life and meditatively contemplating on the Dharma for the development of the mind in samadhi and penetrative insight. In addition, according to Śāntideva, it should not be thought that samadhi (calm abiding) is a state of unknowing or mental blankness. Samadhi means to possess a full control over one’s mind, regardless of whether it is allowed to move or made to remain still. When it is allowed to move, it will engage in every kind of virtuous object of focus.4 This excellent practice of solitude to reach at such a profound level of samadhi is considered as the practice of mindfulness which becomes one of the most popular practices of meditative concentration nowadays. By this practice of mindfulness, we can still engage into the daily activities with the social communities, but always strive to possess a full control over the mind by the way of being mindful in every action of speech, body and mind. Then we can remain the mind still with unvirtuous actions, and allow it move with virtuous ones.
In conclusion, solitude is one of the most conducive conditions to meditative concentration. With its two kinds of practice—physical and mental, solitude takes an essential role to keep the mind and body out of the outer and inner distractions, create the favorable circumstances for the development of calm abiding and penetrative insight. Especially, the practice of mindfulness in the profound aspect of solitude is such a skillful means to keep our practical engagement into the modern and busy life nowadays.
Bibliography
Kunzang Pelden. The Nectar of Manjushri’s Speech – A Detailed Commentary on Shantideva’s Way of the Bodhisattva. Translated by The Padmakara Translation Group. London: Shambhala, 2010.

Shantideva. The Way of the Bodhisattva: A Translation of the Bodhicharyavatara. Translated by The Padmakara Translation Group. Boston: Shambhala, 2006.
